“Stephanie Bacastow, portraying the eponymous Mary, effortlessly dominated the stage with her undeniable poise…[she] is perfect in every way and her presence lights up the Opera House stage like a beacon calling her children home.”
MARY POPPINS, PENOBSCOT THEATRE COMPANY
Elaine Bard
Broadway World
“Bacastow, in addition to being more than “fairly pretty” with “rosy cheeks and cheery disposition,” has a lovely soprano voice, which manages to be both light and airy and powerful enough to fill the theater…. [she] lightly and skillfully treads that fine line between self-confidence and arrogance, and as soon as Mary arrives, we realize, like the Banks family, that we are going to be in good, capable hands for the rest of the show.”
MARY POPPINS, PENOBSCOT THEATRE COMPANY
Nan Lincoln
Ellsworth American
“Stephanie Bacastow of New York City is delightfully perfect as the unconventional nanny…her stunningly clear soprano is reminiscent of Julie Andrews’ voice… Bacastow beautifully balances the nanny’s playful side along with a spoonful of sternness…The actress sets the bar high for the rest of the cast but everyone on stage gives equally fine performances.”
MARY POPPINS, PENOBSCOT THEATRE CO.
Judy Harrison
Bangor Daily News
“Kudos also to the quintet of actors — Adam Richardson, Rebecca Pitcher, Stephanie Bacastow, Andrew Marks Maughan, and Leslie Jackson — who act as a kind of chorus, establishing moods and setting scenes, and singing beautifully while doing so.”
A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC, BARRINGTON STAGE CO.
Don Aucoin
The Boston Globe
“Each member of the relatively large and distinguished cast delivers a masterful performance. The collective vocal presentations are both superb and sublime.”
A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC, BARRINGTON STAGE CO.
Marc Savitt
Broadway World
“Dynamic and Commanding.”
As Rosa Bud in THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD.
Satish Reginald and Cayla Berejikian
Washington Square News
Stephanie Bacastow, elegant and blessed with a thrilling soprano voice, soared with “My White Knight” from “The Music Man.”
BROADWAY RISING STARS CONCERT 2018
William Wolf
Wolf Entertainment Guide
“Stephanie Bacastow is sweet perfection as Mimi Merelli, the actress daughter of Tito and Maria.”
A COMEDY OF TENORS, RIVERSIDE THEATER
Pam Harbaugh
Florida Theater On Stage
“In a word, the production is masterful. … And a shout out also to the operatic voice of Stephanie Bacastow in her role as Emily.”
A CHRISTMAS CAROL: THE MUSICAL, WPPAC
Gerry Falco
The Theatre Guide
Stephanie Bacastow brought back memories of Barbara Cook with her delightful performance of “Vanilla Ice Cream,” which Cook introduced in She Loves Me.
54 SINGS BROADWAY'S GREATEST HITS
Ron Forman
Cabaret Scenes